INFLUENCE OF THE PACIFIC
SUPERPLUME ON THE EURASIAN CONTINENT
N.I. FILATOVA
Geological Institute RAS, Pyzhevsky per., 7,
Abstract: The marginal extensional
zone basalts (MEZB) make up Eocene-Holocene sheet volcanoes and lava plateaus
scattered over the eastern Eurasian margin. They are related to the alkaline
and moderate-alkaline series. Based on the comparison of geochemical and
isotopic characte-ristics, MEZB rocks from Eurasian margin and OIB rocks from
the Pacific are members of a WPB-type volcanic assemblage. The presence of EMI
and EMII components is their major similarity. According to
isotope-seismotomographic data, OIB rocks of the Pacific are related to the
lower mantle superplume that generated the vast DUPAL mantle anomaly. The DUPAL
belt is composed of volcanites enriched in mantle components (EMI and EMII) and
Pb isotopes. Similar isotopic DUPAL properties are also typical of alkaline
basalts in the Pacific and Eurasian continental margin. The comprehensive
analysis of seismotomographic data revealed that the major Pacific negative
P-wave superanomaly (corresponding to the Pacific Lower Mantle Superplume) is
attended by a system of subsidiary (lateral) low-velocity anomalies at the
lower and upper mantle levels of the Circum-Pacific region. Therefore, one can
suppose the following scenario of lower mantle upwelling during 60-125 Ma. A
mantle material, which was extended from the major vertical branch of the
Pacific Superplume, migrated across several levels to form the subsidiary
Circum-Pacific network of lower mantle plumes. The model, consisting of one
major superplume and several subsidiary lateral plumes (plumelets) can explain
the appearance of lower mantle material as the source of WPB-volcanism at
shallow mantle levels of the Eurasian margin. The invasion of EM-type lower
mantle substance into upper mantle sections of the Circum-Pacific and adjacent
continental regions was responsible for the development of an anomalous DUPAL
mantle (similar to DUPAL mantle of the Pacific) and the isotopic signature
similarity of MEZB rocks in eastern Asia
and OIB rocks in the Pacific. Dissimilarities of these rocks are related to
different lithosphere environments. The near-surface position (0-350 km) of the
subsidiary lower mantle plumletts at the western Pacific periphery also
promoted the accumulation of WPB-type volcanites at early stages of the
Eurasian margin extension. The volcanites reveal signs of a genetic
relationship with the lower mantle.
I. INTRODUCTION
The
eastern margin of
There
are two general competing opinions connecting the magma formation process
either to the contribution of enriched continental lithospheric sources or to
plumes originating in the upper or lower mantle. Based on the combined
geochemical and geophysical data, the latter model (lower mantle upwelling) is
often thought to be more reliable.
It
is remarkable that in any petrologic genetically model of Cenozoic alkaline
basalts from the marginal extension zones (MEZB) of eastern Asia, data on the
compo-sition of OIB from the central Pacific ocean as chemical indicators of
within-plate basalt (WPB) are used. This portion of the ocean was previously
distinguished as the Southern Pacific Isotopic and Thermal Anomaly (SOPITA)
belonging to DUPAL mantle [6, 26, 48; etc.). The problem of magma source correlation
of MEZB and OIB was usually not discussed, because of the considerable
difference in the geodynamic settings of these volcanic complexes: continental
lithosphere in contrast to intraoceanic area. The problem of the correlation of
components of MEZB and OIB sources has become urgent in connection with the
distribution of the DUPAL anomalous mantle not only in the Indian and Pacific
oceans [20, etc.], but also in a large region of eastern and southeastern Asia
[17, 46; etc.]. It was also shown that both the
II. COMPARATIVE CHARACTERISTICS OF ALKALINE
BASALTS FROM EURASIAN CONTINENTAL MARGIN AND THE
The
extension structures that originated in the Cenozoic at the eastern margin of
Eurasia (
Areas
of MEZB distribution can be exemplified by the Korean Peninsula (Fig. 1) whose
southern and northern parts and Jejudo Island have been extensively studied
[12-15; etc.]. In this territory and adjacent regions of northeastern China,
islands of the Sea of Japan, and southwestern and central parts of Honshu
Island, Japan (Fig. 1), volcanic occurrences related to continental margin
destruction were dated from the Eocene up to present time [11, 19, 29, 31, 47,
57; etc.]. Despite their general affinity to WPB-type alkaline series, the
Cenozoic MEZB of this region are characterized by rather wide variations of
geochemical and isotopic parameters, which reveal sometimes the presence of a
subduction-related component. The situation is complicated by the local
occurrence of Early Miocene tholeiitic basalts, which correspond to the
spreading stage of the
All
rocks belong to WPB type and range from strongly alkaline, transitional, to tholeiitic
basalts. Fractional silicic volcanic form minor volume. Their trace element
profiles are characterized by incompatible element enrichment similar to DUPAL
ocean island basalts. The isotopic composition clearly depicting the
involvement of DUPAL components. The MEZB of the alkaline and moderate-alkaline
series are characterized by high Nb, Ta, and Zr concentrations, elevated LaN /YbN values, and the P-OIB signature [1, 4, 13, 24, 40, 41;
etc.). The tholeiitic basalts form a lenticular body of primarily E-MORB rocks
in the thick Cenozoic (alkaline MEZB) sequence.
On
the whole, the Cenozoic MEZB of eastern
The
isotopic compositions of MEZB also show resemblances to OIB compositions
plotting above the NHRL, within the enriched I-MORB (or the DUPAL anomaly)
fields. Although MEZB do not include all the extreme isotopic end-members that
are found in OIB [59], their concentrations of radiogenic isotopes are
considerably scattered. The relationships 143Nd/144Nd–87Sr/86Sr
of the Miocene-Holocene alkaline basalts (with occasional flows of enriched
tholeiitic basalts) from
All
the Cenozoic MEZB of the Korea-Japan region and the tholeiitic basalts of the
Thus,
the Sr, Nd, and Pb isotopic compositions of the MEZB are located between three
end-members: enriched MORB, EMI, and EMII, and the former two components are
predominant. The lateral isotopic heterogeneity of the alkaline volcanic
suggests their relationships to different sources rather than mixing of magmas
with contrasting isotopic characteristics.
It
is important to point out that WPB-type rocks accompanying Cenozoic extensional
structures of other regions of the eastern Eurasian margin exhibit relationships
to the same extreme components, MORB, EMI, and EMII (i.e., characteristics of
DUPAL anomaly). The proportions of these three constituents vary over the area.
For instance, the Cenozoic alkaline basalts of northeastern China form a trend
between DMM and EMI on the 143Nd/144Nd - 87Sr/86Sr,
87Sr/86Sr - 206Pb/204Pb, and 207Pb/204Pb
- 206Pb/204Pb diagrams with a minor role of EMII [4, 53;
etc.]. In contrast, the basalts of
The
OIB of the
The
comparison of the isotopic compositions of the Cenozoic MEZB of the continental
margin and Cretaceous-Cenozoic Pacific OIB demonstrated their substantial
similarity and certain differences. The available data on the Korea-Japan
region suggest that MEZB contain isotopic groups similar to those distinguished
among the Pacific OIB. Group 1 of OIB (dominated by EMII) are similar to some
basalts from Ulreungdo and Oki-Dozen islands. These rocks are close to the
Cretaceous OIB of Hemler (Magellan chain) and Wilde (Wake Archipelago)
seamounts and the Cenozoic OIB of the Samoa, Societies, and some of the
No
complete analogues of OIB group 3 with a significant contribution from the
N-MORB component were found among the alkaline rocks of the Korea-Japan region.
Nevertheless, the basalts from the Phohang graben, some rocks of the Chugaryong
area in
Thus,
the principal similarity between the isotopic compositions of the Pacific OIB
and MEZB of the continental margin is related to the presence of alkaline
basalts with EMI and EMII characteristics. On other hand, in comparison with
the OIB, the MEZB are isotopically less variable and show no evidence for the
influence of HIMU and depleted mantle compositions (DMM). The MORB-like
component in the alkaline basalts of the Korea-Japan region was found only in
combination with EM components. Tholeiitic basalts similar to MORB were formed
only in extension zones during the opening of the
Figure 1. Scheme
of distribution of Cenozoic intraplate-type volcanics in the eastern Asian
margin, Sea of Japan, and southwestern
1-12)
Ages of intraplate volcanic of various regions: 1) Paleocene; 2)
Eocene-Pliocene; 3) Neogene; 4) Holocene; and 5) Holocene complexes of
northeastern China [11, 34, 35, 53, 58] and the Sikhote Alin region, Russia
[43]; 7) Early Miocene; 8) Middle
Miocene; and 9) Holocene (a- areas and b- out of scale exposures) complexes
of Korea [12, 13, 19, 47, 57]; 10)
Early-Middle Miocene; 11) Late Miocene - Pliocene, and 12) Pliocene-Holocene
(a- areas and b- out of scale exposures) complexes of the Sea of Japan and
southwestern Japan [31, 39, 40, 44, 45, 52]; 13-16) Crust of the Sea of Japan [51]: 13) Continental; 14)
Destructed continental; 15) Continental affected by rifting and dispersed
spreading, and 16) Newly formed marginal sea; 17) Number of deep-sea boreholes;
18) Sea bottom isobaths; 19) Main faults (strike-slip and, occasionally,
normal); 20) Gravitation step [19, 30]; 21) Compression zone in the Sea of
Japan [27, etc.]; and 22) Deep-sea trench.
The
separating Cenozoic volcanic areas of
The
inset shows three areas discussed in the paper (numerals in squares): 1)
eastern Asia-Japan; 2) Darvin Rise; and 3)
In
addition to the contours of the continents, lithosphere plate boundaries are
also shown: 1) convergent; 2) divergent; and 3) transform.
Figure 2. Model
of dynamics of the Middle Cretaceous - Cenozoic Pacific super-plume (oceanic
slabs are not depicted).
a) Superplume and related
OIB volcanism of 120-80 Ma, modified after [26]. The lower mantle hot material
of the superplume (gray) carries fragments of recycled oceanic crust of
different ages (black). The upper portion of the superplume and plumelets
separating from it are compositionally heterogeneous (Figs. 2c, 2d, see text
for further explanation).
b) The dynamics of the
superplume (gray) and related OIB and MEZB volcanism during the
Cretaceous-Cenozoic. The relationship of the superplume with the lateral plumes
of the western Pacific margin is shown on the basis of a synthesis of seismic
tomography images [55]. The continental lithosphere is shown by vertical
hatching, and the oceanic lithosphere, by slanting hatching.
c) A spatial and temporal
model for the activity of numerous plumelets of varying age (white, gray, and
black) illustrating the possibility of the superposition in a single area of
basalts of several age intervals. The vertical arrow shows ascending plumelets;
the horizontal arrow, direction of oceanic plate movement; the thin horizontal
line, the lower lithosphere boundary; and t1, t2, and t3
are the sequential time intervals of basalt area formation. The latter are
shown in the lower age-distance diagram as filled, unfilled, and gray circles,
respectively [26].
d) A model explaining a
sharp change in the isotopic characteristic of basalts within a single volcanic
chain owing to the action of plumelets of
various ages (for t1, t2, and t3
intervals) and compositions (in this case, HIMU is white and EM is black). The
lower chart shows the spatial and isotopic (206Pb/204Pb)
correlations [26].
III. DEEP STRUCTURE OF THE
Later
studies [17, 46; etc.] demonstrated that similar DUPAL-like isotopic anomalies occupied
a considerable area in southeastern and eastern Asia (together with adjacent
marginal basins and the Korea-Japan region, which is discussed in this paper)
up to the latitude of
The
western and central segments of the Pacific Ocean (SOPITA region) show a swell
on the geoid surface, elevated heat flow, and low velosity anomalies (LVa) of
seismic P-waves in the underlying mantle [10, 18, 36, 38, 48, 50, 55; etc.].
All these data (together with magnetometer results) formed a basis for
understanding the mechanism of mantle upwelling and reconstruction of the
Middle Cretaceous Pacific lower mantle superplume. During the
Cretaceous-Holocene, this superplume has supplied to the surface heat energy and
relatively undepleted material [18, 32, 33, 37, 49; etc.], which was the main
source of OIB. The origin of Pacific superplume was a result of subduction of
the coldest oceanic slab corresponding to high velocity anomalies (HVa) of
P-wave to the hottest mantle [38]. The HVa immediately above the core-mantle
boundary (CMB) within the
On
the global scale, seismic tomography studies have showed the complex structure
of vertical ascending plumes and the possibility of lateral movement of hot
mantle material with branching out of daughter plumes at various levels often
separating from the main body. The daughtert plumes can also lose contact with
the main feeding plume [5, 55; etc.]. The high lateral mobility of low-density
lower mantle intercalating vertically with high-velocity anomalies (HVa) of
subducted oceanic slabs results in a layered distribution of materials with
different seismic properties in the mantle [37; etc.].
In
the periphery of the
It
is worth to note that the arcuate LVa in the western periphery of the
In
contrast to the arcuate LVa in the
western periphery, the Pacific low-velocity superanomaly is traced continuously
through the upper and lower mantle to a depth of 2700 km showing a varying
morphology. At middle and lower mantle depths (1270 to 2670 km), the
superanomaly is composed of two channels of lower mantle upwelling: western
Pacific and southern Pacific. The Pacific superanomaly is rootless on the
whole: the corresponding area at the CMB is occupied by an extended
high-velosity P-waves anomaly [50, 55] corresponding to the ancient slab
graveyard.
The
tomographic data revealed expansion of the superplume head at depths of
1470-1870 km and even more extensive lateral enlargment of lower mantle
material at middle (1270-1470 km) and upper mantle (35-200 km) levels. This was
accompanied by the formation of arcuate lateral plumes in the western Pacific
margin. Thus, the synthesis of distribution of low-velocity seismic anomalies
in the mantle revealed the Pacific superplume of complex morphology and
spatially related circum-Pacific arcuate "layer" bodies at several
depth levels. This model allows us to explain the appearance of deep-derived
lower mantle material in the shallow upper mantle of the periphery and
continental framing of the
IV. MECHANISM OF INFLUENCE OF PACIFIC SUPERPLUME ON THE EURASIAN CONTINENTAL MARGIN
A
variety of geological, geochemical, isotopic, and geophysical data suggests
that the unusually extensive Middle-Cretaceous lower mantle upwelling resulted
in formation of Cretaceous-Holocene WPB-type basalts in the inner parts of the
The
beginning of the superplume activity in the
The
similarity of isotopic and geochemical characteristics of OIB from the Darwin
Rise and
Thus,
the earliest activity of the Pacific superplume produced OIB with EMI
signatures. This component enriched the asthenospheric sources of P-MORB in the
Middle Cretaceous. These data support the opinion [21, etc.] on the lower
mantle nature of the EMI component. Basalts of EMII compositions were
predominant in at the Cenozoic stages of superplume activity. It is conceivable
that EMII has also a lower mantle nature, at least in part. In contrast to the
EM components, the HIMU component of OIB is not genetically linked with the
lower mantle matter of superplume. According to [21, 23, 59; etc.], HIMU
basalts are distributed also outside the DUPAL anomaly. For instance, the
presence of the HIMU component in the Jurassic-Early Cretaceous MORB before the
beginning of the Middle Cretaceous superplume activity. The DMM component of
OIB reflects involvement of depleted asthenospheric sources into magma
formation.
In
order to elucidate dynamics of intraplate magmatism within the Pacific region,
it is necessary to account for the general shift of its occurrence with time
from northwest to southeast (in accord with oceanic plate motion), repeated
renewal of volcanism within individual sites, and mosaic distribution of OIB
with contrasting isotopic characteristics. For instance, along the Marshall chain,
the basalts of Ratak Guyot, Bicar Guyot, Erikub Atoll, and Majuro Atoll with
pronounced HIMU signatures are abruptly changed by the basalts of
It
was shown previously [37; etc.] that plumes of various orders could separate
from the Pacific superplume at boundary mantle levels. According to the model
[26], the entire compositionally heterogeneous SOPITA volcanism was related to
the activity of high-order idividual plumes (plumelets, daughter plumes, hot
fingers), which ascended from the head of the superplume and often separated
spatially from it transforming into rootless bodies (Fig. 2). Such plumelets
differ usually in age (Fig. 2) but could also function simultaneously in
various portions of the large SOPITA area. An abrupt change of a particular OIB
isotopic composition within an individual volcanic chain and appearance of
volcanics with contrasting isotopic signatures suggest the extinction of an
individual plumelet and origination of another, if they were connected with
different areas of the heterogeneous feeding superplume (Fig. 2). There are
several possible reasons for the separation of plumelets from the main plume including
instability at the boundary of two substances with different viscosities, shear
strain at the boundary of these two media, and upper mantle convection.
The
model of action of numerous plumelets connecting with the main superplume can
be aplied to explain the Cenozoic WPB-type volcanism of the western continental
framing of the
Symptomatically,
the tholeiitic volcanics of the Early Miocene stage of the
Previously,
the shallow position of the sources of Cenozoic alkaline magmattism in the
continental margin was used as a basis for the conclusion on their genetic
relation (as well as EMI and EMII) to upper mantle levels of the cratonic
lithosphere [4, 43, 46, 53, 56; etc.]. This contradicted the opinion [3, 40,
41; etc.] on a link between MEZB and a lower mantle plume. The mechanism of the
lateral extending of lower mantle material into various levels of the upper
mantle (Fig. 2) eliminates this contradiction.
The
penetration of lower mantle material (enriched in EMI and EMII) into the upper
mantle of the perioceanic and adjacent continental regions, which was supported
by seismic tomography and isotopic geochemistry, was responsible for the
appearance in this territory of anomalous mantle with DUPAL characteristics [7,
17, 43; etc.], i.e., similar to the DUPAL mantle of the Indian and Pacific
Oceans. In addition, the existence of a system of perioceanic lateral plumes
(often transformed into rootless bodies) explains the mechanism of formation of
the "marble cake" structure of the upper mantle, i.e. an alternation
of depleted and enriched mantle areas.
A
specific feature of the Cenozoic volcanism in the Eurasian margin is the
influence of a subduction component on the early melt portions erupted in MEZB
grabens. This influence strongly decreased with time and is hardly
distinguishable or absent in the Miocene-Quaternary alkaline basalts. The
presence of this component in the alkaline basalts of the continental margin
(completely missing in the SOPITA OIB) is understandable. At least during the
entire Late Mesozoic, the lithospheric mantle of the Eurasian margin occured in
the suprasubduction environment of the Katasian magmatic belt and was affected
by intense fluid metasomatism. In this respect, amphibole-phlogopite domains of
the cratonic mantle, wich are old suprasubduction magma chambers imparted IAB
signatures to early WPB-type melt portions of the Cenozoic extension zones.
Thus, this Mesozoic suprasubduction component had no genetic relation to the
superplume, neither to the EMI and EMII components nor ancient modified
recycled oceanic crust entrained by the superplume at various levels.
Isotopic
studies revealed a mosaic character of the lateral distribution of Cenozoic
basalts dominated by a particular component, E-MORB, EMI, or EMII, in the
extensional zones of the continental margin. This suggest that spatially
separated magma sources of the WPB type with different isotopic characteristics
were manifested nearly contemporaneously during the Cenozoic. Thus, WPB from
the continental margin zone also supports the mechanism of plumelet (hot
finger) activity connected with various parts of a heterogeneous lateral plume
that branching out from the Pacific superplume. Such plumelets could occur in
different spatial and temporal combinations (Fig.2), which resulted in the
spatial dispersion of separated MEZB areas.
V. CONCLUSION
The
comparision of chemical and isotopic properties of the Cenozoic basalts of
extensional zones (MEZB) of eastern Asia and Cretaceous-Cenozoic OIB of the Pacific
isotopic and thermal anomaly (SOPITA) was aimed to exhibit their considerable
similarity, primarily, affiliation to WPB-type volcanics and enrichment in EM
components. Certain differences were also revealed. The Cretaceous OIB of the
Darwin Rise and the Cenozoic OIB of Polynesia show the maximum variability in
Sr, Nd, and Pb isotope compositions, which involved four end-members: N-MORB,
HIMU, EMI, and EMII. The composition of MEZB from the Korea-Japan region and
adjacent territories of the Eurasian margin is dominated by EMI and (or) EMII.
There is no evidence for the influence of HIMU, and the most depleted component
is reprsented by compositions similar to E-MORB. In addition, occasionally,
these alkaline basalts show evidence for the influence of the metasomatized
suprasubduction mantle of the continental lithosphere (moderately low Ti
content and Ta-Nb minimum), which does not occur in the Pacific OIB.
The
origin of SOPITA OIB is related to lower mantle superplume ca. 130-120 m.y.
ago, which corresponds to the low-velocity P-waves seismic anomaly (LVa) of
complex morphology. Global seismic tomographic images of various levels [55]
demonstrated that this main superanomaly gives rise to a system of lateral
circum-Pacific low-velocity anomalies forming a half-ring perioceanic
structure. In the western periphery of the
Thus,
it is reasonable to suggest that the system of the Pacific superplume and
branching lateral plumes was a general cause of WPB magmatism in the islands of
the Darwin Rise and
Melt
evolution at the formation of OIB is evolved from EMI-dominated compositions in
the Cretaceous (Darwin Rise islands) to EMII-dominated ones in the Cenozoic
(Polynesian islands). The initial stage of the Pacific superplume was
accompained not only by OIB formation with EMI signatures but also by the
enrichment MORB in this component, which suggest on the lower mantle nature of
EMI. 3He/4He data
suggest lower mantle origin of EMII component of OIB. The HIMU component
related to ancient modified oceanic lithosphere. In addition, the geterogeneity
of the lower mantle superplume resulted from the involvement of the DMM component
of the oceanic lithosphere. The prolonged formation of the latter in the
The
EMI-dominated isotopic compositions of the China-Korea-Japan MEZB (with local
occurrence of EMII signatures) are indicative of a connection between the
WPB-type Cenozoic volcanics of the continental margin and the lower mantle
material of a shallow later plume. The data of seismic tomography allow
understanding another paradox, the shallow localization of sources of
deepest-derived (with lower mantle isotopic signatures) material feeding the
MEZB. Furthermore, the upwelling of lower mantle from these shallow sources
accompanied by the entering of EMI and EMII components explaines in general the
origination of the DUPAL signatures of the upper mantle of the Eurasian
continental margin and adjacent perioceanic (including the Sea of Japan)
regions.
However,
in contrast to OIB, the composition of MEZB of the Eurasian margin was
influenced (to a degree strongly decreasing with time) by the continental
lithospheric mantle altered metasomatically in a ancient suprasubduction zones.
Another
common property of the Pacific OIB and MEZB of eastern
This
work was supported by the Russian
REFERENCES
1. Allan J.F., Gorton М.Р, 1992.
Geochemistry of igneous rocks from legs 127 and 128,
2.
3. Baker P.E., Castillo P.R.,
and Condliffe E, 1995.
Petrology and geochemistry of igneous rocks from Allison and Resolution
Guyots, sites 865 and 866. Proc. ODP Sci. Results, 143: 245-261.
College station.
4. Basu A.R., Wang J.W., Huang
W.G. et al, 1991. Major element, REE, Pb, Nd, and Sr isotopic
geochemistry of Cenozoic volcanic rocks of
5. Bijwaard H., Spakman W.,
Engdahl E.R, 1998. Closing the gap between regional and travel time
tomography. J. Geophys. Res., 103/12: 30055-30078.
6. Castillo P., 1988. The
DUPAL anomaly as a trace of the upwelling lower mantle. Nature, 336: 667-670.
7. Cousens B.L., Allan J.F, 1992. A Pb,
Sr, and Nd isotopic study of basaltic rocks from the
8. Davis A.S., Pringle L.G.,
Pickthorn D.A. et al, 1989. Petrology and age of alcalic
lava from the Ratak Chain of the
9. Dupre B., Allegre C.J., 1983. Pb-Sr isotope variation in
10. Dziewonski A., 1984.
Mapping the lower mantle: Determination of lateral heterogenity in P-velocity
up to degree and order 6. J.
Geophys. Res., 89: 5929-5952.
11. Fan Q., Hooper P.R., 1991. The
Cenozoic basaltic rocks of
12. Fedorchuk A.V., Filatova
N.I., 1993. Cenozoic
magmatism of
13. Fedorov P.I., Filatova N.I.,
2002. Cenozoic volcanism of the
14. Filatova N.I., Chang K.Kh.,
1999. Late Mesozoic lateral series of conditions of sediment accumulation in
the Korea-Japan Region. Dokl. Russ. Akad.
Nauk, 369/1: 100-104.
15. Filatova N.I., Fedorov P.I.,
2001. Cenozoic magmatism in the extension zones of continental margins: An
example of the Korea-Japan area. J.
Petrologiya, 9/5: 519-546.
16. Filatova N.I., Fedorov P.I.,
2003. Cenozoic magmatism in the Korean-Japanese region and its geodynamic
setting. Geotectonics, 1: 49-70.
17. Flower M., Tamaki K., Hoang
N., 1998. Mantle extrusion: A model for dispersed volcanism and DUPAL-like
asthenosphere in
18. Fukao Y., Maruyama S.,
Obayashi M., Inone H., 1994. Geological implication of the whole mantle
P-wave tomography. J. Geol. Soc. Japan,
100: 4-23.
19. Geologiya Korei, 1993. The
Geology of
20. Hart S.R., 1984. A
large-scale isotope anomaly in the southern hemisphere mantle. Nature, 309: 753-757.
21. Hart S.R., 1988.
Heterogeneous mantle domains: Signatures, genesis and mixing chronologies. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett., 90: 273-296.
22. Hofman A.W., White W.M.,
1982. Mantle plumes from ancient oceanic crust. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett., 57/4: 421-436.
23. Hofman A.W., 1997. Mantle
geochemistry: The message from oceanic volcanism. Nature, 385/6613: 219-229.
24. Iwamori H., 1992. Degree
of melting and source composition of Cenozoic basalts in southwest
25. Janney Ph.E., Castillo P.R.,
1997. Geochemistry on Mesozoic Pacific mid-ocean ridge basalt: Constraints
on melt generation and the evolution of the Pacific upper mantle. J. Geophys. Res., 102/B3: 5207-5229.
26. Janney Ph.E., Castillo P.R.,
1999. Isotope geochemistry of the Darwin Rise seamounts and the nature of
long-term mantle dynamics beneath the south central Pacific. J. Geoph. Res., 104/B5: 10571-10589.
27. Jolivet L., Tamaki K., 1992. Neogene
kinematics of the
28. Jolivet L., Shubuya H.,
Fournier M., 1995. Paleomagnetic rotations and
29.
30. Kang P.Ch., Cho J.D., Choi
J.H, et al., 1996. Bouguer gravity anomaly map, the southern part of
31. Kim K.H., Tanaka T., Nagao
K., Jang S.K., 1999. Nd and Sr isotopes and K-Ar ages of the
Ulreungdo alkaline volcanic rocks in the East Sea, South Korea. Geochem. J., 33/5: 317-341.
31. Kurasawa H., 1968.
Isotopic composition of lead and concentration of uranium, thorium and lead in
volcanic rocks from Dogo of the Oki islands,
32. Larson R.L., Olson P., 1991. Mantle
plumes control magnetic reversal frequency. Earth
Planet. Sci. Lett., 107: 437-447.
33. Larson R.L., 1991. Latest
pulse of Earth: Evidence for a Mid-Cretaceous superplume. Geology, 19: 547-550.
34. Lee J.S., Pouclet A., 1988. Le
volcanisme Néogène de Pohang (
35. Liu J., 1987. Study
on geochronology of the Cenozoic volcanic rocks in
36. Loper D.E., Lay T., 1995. The
core-mantle boundary region. J. Geophys.
Res., 100/B4: 6397-6420.
37. Maruyama Sh., 1994. Plume
tectonics. J. Geol. Soc. Japan, 100/1:
24-49.
38. Maruyama Sh., Santosh M.,
Zhao D., 2007. Superplume, supercontinent, and post-perovskite:
Mantle dynamics and anti-plate tectonics on the Core-Mantle boundary. Gondwana Res., 11: 7-37.
39. Morris P.A., Kagami H., 1989. Nd and
Sr isotope systematics of Miocene to Holocene volcanic rocks from Southwest
Japan: Volcanism since the opening of the
40. Nakamura E., Campbell J.H.,
McCullouch M.T., and Sun Sh.-S., 1989. Chemical geodynamics in a back
arc region around the Sea of Japan: Implications for the genesis of alkaline
basalts in
41. Nakamura E., McCullouch
M.T., Campbell J.H., 1990. Chemical geodynamics in the back arc region
of
42. Nguyen H., Flower M.F.J.,
Corlson R.W., 1996. Major trace elements and isotopic composition of
Vietnamese basalts: Interaction of hydrous EMI-rich asthenosphere with thinned
Eurasian lithosphere. Geochim. Cosmochim.
Acta, 60/22: 4329-4351.
43. Okamura S., Arculus R.J.,
Martynov Yu.A. et al., 1998. Multiple magma sources involved in
marginal-sea formation: Pb, Sr, and Nd isotopic evidences from the
46. Smith A.D., 1998. The
geodynamic significance of the DUPAL anomaly in
47. Song S., Lee H.K., Yun H.,
1997. Petrogenesis of the Tertiary volcanic rocks from the southeastern part
of
48. Staudigel H., Park K.H.,
Pringle M. et al., 1991. The longevity of the South Pacific isotopic
and thermal anomaly. Earth Planet. Sci.
Lett., 102: 24-44.
49. Stein M., Hofmann A.W.,
1994. Mantle plumes and episodic crustal growth. Nature,
372/3: 63-68.
50. Su W.-J., Woodward R.L.,
Dziewonski A.M., 1994. Degree 12 model of shear velocity heterogeneity
in the mantle. J. Geophys. Res., 99/B4:
6945-6980.
51. Tatsumoto M., Nakamura Y.,
1991. DUPAL anomaly in the
52. Tamaki K., Suyehiro K.,
Allan S., et al., 1992. Tectonic synthesis and implications of the
Japan Sea ODR drilling. Proc. ODR Sci.
Res., 127/128-2: 1333-1350.
53. Tatsumoto M., Basu A.R.,
Huang W. et al., 1992. Sr, Nd and Pb isotopes of ultramafic
xenoliths in volcanic rocks of eastern
54. Turner S., Hawkesworth
55. Vasco D.W., Johnson L.R.,
1998. Whole Earth structure estimated from seismic arrival times. J. Geoph. Res., 103/132: 2633-2671.
56. Wang J., Xie G., Tatsumoto
M., Basu A.R., 1989. Sr, Nd, Pb isotope geochemistry and magma
evolution of the potassic volcanic rocks, Wudalianchi,
57. Yun S.H., Won Ch.K., Lee
M.W., 1993. Cenozoic volcanic activity and petrochemistry of
volcanic rocks in the Mt. Paektu Area. J.
Geol. Soc. Korea, 29/3: 291-307.
58. Zhang M., Zhou X.-M., Zhang
J.-B., 1998. Nature of the lithosphere mantle beneath
59. Zindler A., Hart S., 1986.
Chemical geodynamics. Ann. Rev. Earth
Planet. Sci., 14/2: 493-541