ON THE AGE AND GEOLOGICAL SETTINGS
OF THIÊN NHẪN FORMATION IN NORTH TRUNG BỘ, VIỆT NAM

SHIGEKI HADA1, TRẦN VĂN TRỊ2, ĐOÀN NHẬT TRƯỞNG3

1Research Institute for Higher Education, Kobe University, Kobe, Japan
2Việt Nam Union of Geological Sciences, 6 Phạm Ngũ Lão, Hà Nội
3Research Institute of Geology and Mineral Resources, Thanh Xuân, Hà Nội

Abstract: The Thiên Nhẫn Formation occuring in North Trung Bộ, Việt Nam was established and supposedly dated as Early-Middle Triassic by Mareitchev A. and Zhamoida A. [1], but in the description the stratotype was not indicated. The lectostratotype described in this paper extends from Yên Vực through the Thiên Nhẫn Mt to Thịnh Hương Village, Hương Sơn District, Hà Tĩnh Province. The formation is characterized mainly by thin-, parallel-bedded, rhythmic of turbidite type cherty shale, argillaceous-cherty shale, manganese-bearing chert with a thickness of about 800 m, containing in abundance radiolarians, conodonts, but the fossils were deformed and fragmented. However, there have been determined some forms of the family Entactiniidae, Albaillellidae of Middle-Late Paleozoic and Ozarkodina (Spathognathodus) sp., especially Palmatolepis sp. close to P. glabra lepta of Late Devonian, possibly Frasnian. The above sediments and fossils characterize the pelagic environment of the Việt-Laos branch basin of PaleoTethys lying between the Indochina and Sino - Việt Nam blocks, that joins the PaleoTethys lying between the Indochina and Shan-Thai blocks. The flyschoid and/or turbidite cherty shale can be correlated with the complex of accretionary prism of the Trường Sơn Fold Belt formed during Hercynian and Indosinian syn-collision orogenics.


During recent years, the collaboration between the Department of Geology and Minerals of Việt Nam and the Japanese Kobe University and American CONOCO and UNOCAL Company has been allowing to collect many new data, among them new materials on the Thiên Nhẫn Formation.

I. LECTOSTRATOTYPE

The Thiên Nhẫn Formation was established by Mareitchev A. and Zhamoida A. in 1965 [1], named by the name of Thiên Nhẫn Mt situated in northeast of the Hương Sơn District, Hà Tĩnh Province, and supposedly dated as Early-Middle Triassic, but its stratotype was not indicated. This formation occurs in a narrow band of 3-6 km in width, extending in NW-SE direction in the west of the Thanh Chương and Nam Đàn districts, Nghệ An Province, through Hương Sơn, Đức Thọ to Kỳ Anh districts, Hà Tĩnh Province in a length of over 150 km, limited in the two sides by tectonic faults.

During recent years, the authors of this paper had supplementary surveys and established the lectostratotype for the formation along the road from Yên Vực (18°34’30” N; 105°33’12” E) situated in the west of the former Road No.15A, extending through the Thiên Nhẫn Mt to Thịnh Hương (18°33:15” N; 105°31’45” E), situated in the left side of the Ngàn Phố River, Hương Sơn District, Hà Tĩnh Province. The formation in this section was crosscut by many fault, and complicatedly folded and deformed, therefore, it is difficult to recognize the lowermost and uppermost parts of the section. However, according to the attitude and lithological composition of the beds one can distinguish 3 parts of the formation as follows.

Lower part: light-grey, dull-white but violetish-brown, dark-yellow by weathering argillaceous-cherty shale, cherty shale and cherty mudstone rhythmically interbedded with each interbed of some to some tens cm in thickness. In this part, locally there still are interbeds (4-7 cm) of siltstone and fine-grained sandstone. Thickness: over 200 m.


Plate 1.  Conodonts fossils

                                       1-4, 6. Ozarkodina (Spathognathodus) sp.

5. Palmatolepis sp., a- upper side views; b- lateral side views

The line fragments are equal to 0.1 mm


Middle part: mainly of dark-grey, light-grey, thin- and parallel-bedded cherty shale, chert, rhythmically interbedded with argillaceous-cherty shale, usually broken into angular fragments or small plates. Particularly, in many places there still are interbeds of cherty, argillaceous-cherty breccia or manifestations of manganese hydroxide and iron-manganese oxide. Thickness: about 350 m.

Upper part: greenish-grey argillaceous-cherty shale rhythmically interbedded with dull-white, pinkish, parallel-banded cherty mudstone; besides there still are interbeds of dark-grey cherty limestone (30-40 cm), cherty breccia and manganese manifestations. Thickness: over 250 m.

The total thickness of the formation in this section is about 800 m.

II. PALEONTOLOGICAL BASIS

Fossils in the Thiên Nhẫn Formation were found only in recent years. They are almost deformed, recrystallized and broken into small fragments, among them radiolarians are widespread together with some conodonts that are difficult for specific determination, however, among them some can be determined.


Plate 2. 1-4. Radiolarian fossils

The line fragments are equal to 0.05 mm


The sample 020818 (18°30’50” N; 105°34’10” E by GPS) consists of cherty shale collected from exposures situated in the southern talus of the Road No. 8, extending from the Linh Cảm Bridge to Châu Sơn, Châu Lĩnh villages, Tùng Ảnh Commune, Đức Thọ District, Hà Tĩnh Province, containing the conodont Ozarkodina (Spathognathodus) sp. (Photo 1-4, 6, Plate 1) of from Late Silurian to Carboniferous age; especially the specimen 1 is similar to Ozarkodina semialternans of Middle-Late Devonian age. The Photo 5 is Palmatolepis sp. having a large, asymmetrical platform with the curved, but still preserved main tooth, and morphologically similar to Palmatolepis glabra lepta of Late Devonian age (Plate 1). Besides, there still are many radiolarians, but of bad preservation.


Figure 1. Hill scarp situated in the south of Road No.8, in 3 km east of the Linh Cảm Bridge: rhythmically thin-bedded, monoclinal manganese-bearing cherty shale

Photo: Hada S.

Figure 2. Hill scarp situated in 200 m southeast of the Linh Cảm Bridge:  thin-bedded cherty shale rhythmically interbedded with clayey-cherty shale, forming overturned folds destroyed by faults.

Photo: Hada S.


The sample 020818-8 (18°30’50” N; 105°34’25” E by GPS) situated in 500 m east of the exposure 020818-4 and in 300 m south of the Road No.8, collected from a cherty shale scarp in the hill slope, contains also many conodont fossils and, especially, very many radiolarian remains, but also of bad preservation, that does not allow to determine to genus and species (Plate 2).

Also in this road section, the American CONOCO Inc. in collaboration with the Department of Geology and Minerals of Việt Nam has been collecting the chert sample 12/15/1 in the road talus (18°31’ N; 105°35’ E) containing in abundance radiolarian remains of very bad preservation, but according to Stanley A. Kling, California, USA some specimens can be determined as of the Entactiniidae family of from Devonian to Permian age, and some specimens can be determined as of the Albaillidae family of from Mississippi to Permian age, and the common age of host rocks can be Middle-Late Paleozoic. 

III. GEOLOGICAL RELATIONS

The lower and upper boundaries of the Thiên Nhẫn Formation have not been observed in any locality yet, because its contact with other formations was destroyed by faults. According to Zhamoida and Mareitchev [1] in the west of the Vũ Liệt Village one can suppose that there is normal attitude of argillaceous shale of the Ladinian Quy Lăng Formation upon cherty shale of the Thiên Nhẫn Formation. Besides, in the north and east of the Height 497 the Thiên Nhẫn Formation rests unconformably upon sandstone and shale of the Sông Cả Formation (O-S sc); as for in the south and northwest of Kỳ Anh Townlet it is covered clearly unconformably by Jurassic volcano-sedimentary beds.

IV. GEOLOGICAL SETTINGS

The lithological composition of the studied formation consists mainly of thin-bedded cherty shale rhythmically interbedded with parallel-banded argillaceous-cherty shale, cherty mudstone, and in some places there are the beds containing manifestations of manganese hydroxide or manganese nodules. Besides, there still are cherty breccias of sedimentary melange type and thin interbeds or lenses of calcareous-cherty shale.

These sediments form a complex of turbidite flysch containing radiolarians and conodonts of the pelagic environment of the Việt-Laos branch basin of the PaleoTethys lying between the Indochina and Sino -Việt Nam blocks, that joins the PaleoTethys lying between the Indochina and Shan-Thai blocks [3]. They were formed in the form of accretionary prism during the process of subduction under the Indosinian microcontinent. The flysch and/or turbidite cherty shale of the Trường Sơn Fold Belt were formed during the Hercynian and Indosinian syn-collision orogenics.

V. AGE AND GEOLOGICAL CORRELATION

The Thiên Nhẫn Formation long ago has been considered as a dumb formation and referred by the authors to different age, such as Silurian-Devonian [2, 8], Triassic [1, 7] and Carboniferous [5, 9].

The recent fossil finding includes abundant collection of radiolarians and conodonts. Although the fossils are in deformed situation, they still allow to determine the conodonts Ozarkodina (Spathgnathodus) sp., O. semialternans. And especially Palmatolepis sp. morphologically close to Palmatolepis glabra lepta of Late Devonian age, possibly Frasnian.

In the southwest of the studied area, on the territory of the Tuyên Hóa District, Quảng Bình Province there is the Ngọc Lâm Formation including also thin-bedded, banded cherty shale, argillaceous-cherty shale with interbeds of manganese hydroxide containing the conodonts Palmatolepis subrecta, Calvinaria cracowiensis, C. cf. megistanus of Frasnian age, lying unconformably upon the Động Thờ Formation (D2gv-D3fr dt) and under the Xóm Nha Formation (D3 xn) [6]. As for in the north, in the area of Cốc, Phùng Giao and Lương Ngọc villages, Thanh Hóa Province, occurs also cherty shale interbedded with argillaceous shale, chert containing manganese supposedly referred  to Upper Permian - Lower Triassic or Upper Devonian [4]. Based on lithological and paleontological characteristics the Ngọc Lâm Formation and cherty shale at Thanh Hóa can be considered as similar to the Thiên Nhẫn Formation. The above presented new materials consist of a part of the collaboration between the Department of Geology and Minerals of Việt Nam and the Japanese Kobe University, the American CONOCO, UNOCAL Companies. The authors express their sincere thanks to these institutions.

REFERENCES

1. Dovzhikov A. E. (Editor), 1965. Geologija Severnogo Vietnama. Objasnitelnaja zapiska k geologitcheskoi karte Severnogo Vietnama, GGU, Hà Nội, 665 tr.

2. Fromaget J. 1927. Etudes géologiques dans le Nord de l’Indochine centrale. Bull. SGI., XVI/2, Hanoi. 368 p.

3. Hada S., Bunopas S., Ishii K. and Yoshikura S., 1999. Rift-drift history and the amalgamation of Shan-Thai and Indochina/Malaya Blocks. In Metcalfe I. (Ed.). Gondwana dispersion and Asian accretion. IGCP 321, Final results volume. A. A. Balkema Publ. Rotterdam. p. 67-87.

4. Lê Văn Cự (Chủ biên), 1980. Khoáng sản miền Bắc Việt Nam. (Mineral resources of North Việt Nam. Vol. 1). Tập 1, 170 tr, Tập III, 78 tr. Tổng cục Địa chất, Hà Nội.

5. Nguyễn Văn Hoành (Chủ biên), 1994. Kết quả hiệu đính Bản đồ địa chất tỷ lệ 1:200.000 loạt tờ Trường Sơn. (Results of the redaction of geological map at 1:200,000 scale of the Trường Sơn sheet series). Bản đồ Địa chất, tr. 83-93. Liên đoàn BĐĐC MB, Hà Nội.

6. Phạm Huy Thông, Tạ Hòa Phương, Nguyễn Hữu Hùng, Đoàn Nhật Trưởng, 1999. Một số tài liệu mới về địa tầng Paleozoi trung-thượng vùng Quy Đạt - Lý Hòa và tồn tại cần được tiếp tục nghiên cứu.  (New data on the Middle-Upper Paleozoic stratigraphy in the Quy Đạt - Lý Hòa area and remaining problems). Địa chất và Khoáng sản Việt Nam, III : 15-24. Liên đoàn BĐĐCMB, Hà Nội.

7. Trần Tính (Chủ biên), 1996. Địa chất và Khoáng sản tờ Hà Tĩnh - Kỳ Anh tỷ lệ 1: 200.000. (Geology and mineral resources of the Hà Tĩnh - Kỳ Anh map sheet at 1:200,000 scale). Cục ĐCVN, Hà Nội, 86 tr.

8. Trần Văn Trị (Chủ biên), 1977. Địa chất Việt Nam. Phần miền Bắc. (Geology of Việt Nam. The North part). Thuyết minh kèm theo bản đồ địa chất tỷ lệ 1:1000.000. Nxb KH & KT, Hà Nội, 355 tr.              

9. Vũ Khúc (Chủ biên), 2000. Sách tra cứu các phân vị địa chất Việt Nam. (Lexicon of geological units of Việt Nam). Cục ĐC & KSVN, Hà Nội, 430 tr.